ADVERSUS “ADVERSUS HOMO ECONOMICUS”: CRITIQUE OF THE “CRITIQUE OF LESTER’S ACCOUNT OF INSTRUMENTAL RATIONALITY”

J. C. Lester

Abstract


This essay goes through Frederick 2015 (the critique) in some detail, responding to the various paraphrases and criticisms therein. It is argued that in each case the critique is mistaken about what Lester 2012 (Escape from Leviathan: EfL) says, or about what the critique presents as a sound criticism, or both. Introduction: the three problems with the critique and the philosophical problem that EfL is attempting to solve. “Abstract”: the critique’s confusion about EfL’s aprioristic theory of instrumental rationality. There are then detailed replies (too many and too diverse to summarise) to quotations from the critique’s confused interpretations and criticisms under the following headings (quoted from the critique): “2. Instrumental Rationality”; 3. Weakness of Will”; “4. Desires and Values”; “5. Free Will”; “6. Self-Interest”; “7. Maximisation”; “8. Morals”. Finally, in “9. Conclusion”, the philosophical problem for economics is briefly restated. The philosophical interpretation of homo economicus in EfL (as with its overall philosophical theory of libertarianism) has yet to be given adequate critical consideration.


Keywords


Homo economicus, instrumental rationality, social libertarianism, weakness of will, desires and values, free will, self-interest, categorical morals

Full Text:

PDF

References


Frederick, D. (2013). A Critique of Lester’s Account of Liberty. Libertarian Papers 5(1), 45-66. Retrieved from Libertarian Papers: libertarianpapers.org.

Frederick, D. (2015). Adversus Homo Economicus: Critique of Lester’s Account of Instrumental Rationality. Retrieved from Academia: https://www.academia.edu/2037838/Adversus_Homo_Economicus_Critique_of_Lester_s_Account_of_Instrumental_Rationality

Hare, R. M. (1986, [1952]). The Language of Morals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lester, J. C. (2016. [2011]). Arguments for Liberty: A Libertarian Miscellany, 2nd ed. Buckingham: The University of Buckingham Press.

Lester, J. C. (2012, [2000]). Escape from Leviathan: Libertarianism without Justificationism. Buckingham: The University of Buckingham Press.

Lester, J. C. (2014). Explaining Libertarianism: Some Philosophical Arguments. Buckingham: The University of Buckingham Press.

Lester, J. C. (2017). Two Dialogues: Introductions to Philosophy and Libertarianism. Buckingham: The University of Buckingham Press.

Percival, R. S. (2012). The Myth of the Closed Mind: Understanding Why and How People Are Rational. Chicago and La Salle, Illinois: Open Court.

Simon, H. (1997). Administrative Behavior, 4th ed. New York: The Free Press.

Watson, G. (1975). Free Agency. Journal of Philosophy 72(8): 205-220.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.