DOES TRESPASSING REQUIRE HUMAN ACTION? REJOINDER TO KINSELLA AND ARMOUTIDIS ON EVICTIONISM

Walter E. Block

Abstract


Libertarian scholars Kinsella and Armoutidis criticize the libertarian theory of evictionism. This is a principled compromise between the pro-life and the pro-choice positions. Its conclusion overlaps with the former in the last trimester of pregnancy and with the latter in the first two trimesters. That is, the pregnant mother may expel the fetus from her body whenever she wishes but may not ever kill this pre-born baby. This theory is predicated upon the notion that the unwanted fetus is a trespasser; an innocent one, to be sure. Thus, he may be expelled from her body, her private property, but not treated as a criminal, since he is innocent of any crime. Evictionism stands or falls on this one claim. If the fetus is not a trespasser, this solution to the abortion controversy is a failure. Kinsella (2023) and Armoutidis (2024) maintain, to the contrary, that trespassing is a human action, and that the fertilized egg, the beginning of human life, is capable of nothing such thing. This  essay aims to refute their position.

Keywords


Abortion, Pro-life, Pro-choice, Trespass, Evictionism, Property rights, Abortion debate

Full Text:

PDF

References


Armoutidis, C. (2024). Preargumentation ethics and the issue of abortion. Journal of Libertarian Studies, 28(1), 67–75. https://doi.org/10.35297/001c.117156

Block, W. E. (1977a). Toward a libertarian theory of abortion. The Libertarian Forum, 10(9), 6–8. http://www.mises.org/journals/lf/1977/1977_09.pdf

Block, W. E. (1977b). L’aborto: Una legittima difesa. Claustrofobia, 1(3), 16–22.

Block, W. E. (1978). Abortion, woman and fetus: Rights in conflict? Reason, 9(12), 18–25.

Block, W. E. (2001, September 3). Stem cell research: The libertarian compromise. LewRockwell.com. http://archive.lewrockwell.com/block/block5.html

Block, W. E. (2004). Libertarianism, positive obligations and property abandonment: Children’s rights. International Journal of Social Economics, 31(3), 275–286. https://doi.org/10.1108/03068290410518256

Block, W. E. (2005). Compromising the uncompromisable: A private property rights approach to resolving the abortion controversy. Appalachian Law Review, 4(2), 1–45. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228125532_Compromising_the_Uncompromisable_A_Private_Property_Rights_Approach_to_Resolving_the_Abortion_Controversy

Block, W. E. (2010a). A libertarian perspective on the stem cell debate: Compromising the uncompromisable. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 35(4), 429–448. https://academic.oup.com/jmp/article/35/4/429/945646

Block, W. E. (2010b). Response to Jakobsson on human body shields. Libertarian Papers. http://libertarianpapers.org/2010/25-block-response-to-jakobsson-on-human-body-shields/

Block, W. E. (2011a). The human body shield. Journal of Libertarian Studies, 22(1), 625–630. http://mises.org/journals/jls/22_1/22_1_30.pdf

Block, W. E. (2011b). Response to Wisniewski on abortion, round three [Peer commentary]. Libertarian Papers, 3, Article 37. http://libertarianpapers.org/articles/2011/lp-3-37.pdf

Block, W. E. (2011c). Terri Schiavo: A libertarian analysis. Journal of Libertarian Studies, 22(1), 527–536. http://mises.org/journals/jls/22_1/22_1_26.pdf

Block, W. E. (2012, August 30). A not so funny thing happened to me in Tampa. LewRockwell.com. http://archive.lewrockwell.com/block/block208.html

Block, W. E. (2014a). Should abortion be criminalized? Rejoinder to Akers, Davies and Shaffer on abortion. MEST Journal, 2(1), 33–44. http://fbim.meste.org/FBIM_1_2014/_04.pdf

Block, W. E. (2014b). Evictionism and libertarianism. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 35(2), 290–294. https://doi.org/10.1093/jmp/jhu012

Block, W. E. (2014c). Toward a libertarian theory of evictionism. Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 35(2), 290–294. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10834-013-9361-4

Block, W. E. (2018). Judith Jarvis Thomson on abortion; a libertarian critique. DePaul Journal of Health Care Law, 19(1), Article 3, 48-53. http://via.library.depaul.edu/jhcl/vol19/iss1/3

Block, W. E. (2019). Human shields, missiles, negative homesteading and libertarianism. Ekonomia Wroclaw Economic Review, 25(1), 9–22. http://ekon.wuwr.pl/catalog/-38

Block, W. E. (2021). Evictionism: The compromise solution to the pro-life pro-choice debate controversy. Springer. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-981-16-5014-7

Block, W. E. (2025a). Rejoinder to Wasiak on eviction and negative homesteading. Studia z Historii Filozofii, 1(16). https://doi.org/10.12775/szhf.2025.009

Block, W. E. (2025b). To my critics on evictionism: Response to Dominiak and Wysocki on redundancy, Wąsiak on negative homesteading, Wisniewski on praxeology, Wójtowicz on peril. Studia z Historii Filozofii, 1(16). https://doi.org/10.12775/szhf.2025.010

Block, W. E., & Whitehead, R. (2005). Compromising the uncompromisable: A private property rights approach to resolving the abortion controversy. Appalachian Law Review, 4(2), 1–45. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228125532_Compromising_the_Uncompromisable_A_Private_Property_Rights_Approach_to_Resolving_the_Abortion_Controversy

Dyke, J., & Block, W. E. (2011). Explorations in property rights: Conjoined twins. Libertarian Papers, 3, Article 38. http://libertarianpapers.org/2011/38-dyke-block-conjoined-twins/

Kinsella, S. (2023, June 14). Abortion correspondence with Doris Gordon, Libertarians for Life (1996). StephanKinsella.com. https://www.stephankinsella.com/2023/06/abortion-correspondence-with-doris-gordon-1996/

Kinsella, S., & Tinsley, P. (2023). Causation and aggression. In Legal foundations of a free society (pp. xx–xx). Papinian Press.

McGee, R. W., & Block, W. E. (2022). On abortion: Utilitarianism and deontology. Southern University Law Review, 50, 10–24. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/361732682_On_Abortion_Utilitarianism_and_Deontology




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12709/mest.14.14.01.04

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.